COVID-19: Virtual party kits available!
Play games over video chat with your guests. See virtual game kits

Murder Mystery Party Kit Details

Murder in Manhattan - Mystery Party Kit

Price:
$49.95


Running a for-profit event?

Add a Commercial License

Murder in Manhattan

$49.95
Add intrigue to your next party with this murder mystery game, set at a Manhattan cocktail party.
Format: Mystery Party Kit
Setting: New York cocktail party
Players: 10-25 (Standard Game)
26-100+ (Expanded Game)
Time: 90+ minutes
Ages: Adult
Mystery Party Reviews
Overall Average Rating:
110 reviews
  • Date - Newest First
  • Date - Newest First
  • Date - Latest First
  • Highest Rated
  • Lowest Rated
  • Most Helpful
  • Ownership

1-15 of 118

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. ...
  7. 8
28 01 202307:46 PM
  • more than 1 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
A Party to Die For!
Everyone had such a great time. Party of 14 ages 7-70 and everyone showed up dressed to impress and in character! I wish there was a way for the host to assume more of an active role in the mystery, but I still had an amazing time watching the story unfold infront of me! Definitely want to do it again!
  • Lamb Skewers
    Arancini
    Chianti
    Prosciutto & Melon
    Cannoli
  • Wax Envelopes, all the candles, italian music, bloodied evidence
0
1
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
11 09 202204:05 AM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Halloween party
This party was super fun. I have never run a murder mystery party before (though I’ve participated in them), and don’t find myself to be particularly gifted in this arena, but even I could run this party with ease. It was a ton of fun for my guests, and people has a great time getting into character. It was also a great way to break the ice for a group of people that didn’t all know each other. So fun!
0
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
15 07 202209:28 PM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
A Unique Birthday Party!
I hosted Murder in Manhattan for my birthday this year because I wanted to get my friends together for something different and had always wanted to throw a murder mystery party. Everything went so smoothly and I was surprised that everyone got really into it. I set the game up kind of like an escape room to add some more dimensions to it. It was challenging but not too difficult and everyone had a great time going through the clues to figure out the culprit!
2
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
07 09 202210:24 AM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Awesome experience!
15th Birthday Celebration

Awesome outcome. We purchased the Murder in Manhattan and made it a costume party as well. The party goers were excited and out going for the mystery and it made the dance afterwards even better. Thank you Playing with Murder!
  • Brisket, potato salad, and nachos. We also had a cake made with a knife going down the center.
  • We rented a hall located inside a 100 year old building to set the mood. We decorated with police tape, old candles and murder mystery books as center pieces.
1
1
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
15 05 202203:57 PM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
A celebration to remember!
Murder in Manhattan was a great way to celebrate my 25th birthday with friends! A murder mystery has been long talked about and everyone went all out for this first experience. Looking forward to another very soon!
  • A night of sushi and Taco Bell haha
  • We stuck to black and gold, added wax seals to all the invites, and set the mood with string lights and candles.
2
1
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
27 04 202209:34 PM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
A 21st birthday hit!
Murder in Manhattan was our daughter's 21st birthday party. It took a little prep ahead of time but the kit made everything so easy! The kids came dressed for the part and it was so fun watching them in character all evening! They had a great time learning about all the other characters and trying to figure out who the killer is!
  • We did finger foods during act 1 and birthday cupcakes and sparkling cider during act 2.
  • We decorated in black and gold. We had a photo booth where we used black tablecloths and gold streamers. We had ambiance music playing in the background.
2
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
26 04 202203:16 AM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Whodunnit!
Murder in Manhattan was a success! It was my daughters 21st birthday and we celebrated with about 20 of her friends at college. The kit made it so easy! The prep work ahead of time made the evening go so smoothly! The kids came dressed for their part. It was so much fun watching them in character all evening!
  • We served finger foods for the first act and cupcakes during act 2.
  • We decorated in black and gold. We used black table cloths and gold confetti with candles in the middle for the blackout scene.
2
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
27 03 202207:36 PM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
DINNER WITH A SIDE OF SECRETS
We had a reunion of friends and played out Murder in Manhattan. It was a blast and easy to follow. The scavenger hunt had everyone running around but unfortunately the killer got away!!
  • Tri-tip dinner with a sweet salad and rolls. Red wine, Jack and coke, and non alcoholic sangria to drink.
  • Plenty of candles around the room as well as flashlights. Very high fashion attendees. Played New York Bar Jazz playlist on Spotify.
1
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
25 03 202210:56 PM
  • more than 2 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Murder in Manhattan: A bloody success
This was the second party kit I purchased from Playing with Murder and it was another hit. The info package may seem overwhelming at first but it really isn't too complicated. The characters have great back stories that my friends loved and got really into. I would love if the character info and other info that I needed to print was in smaller font and easier to print double sided - I used a lot of paper and usually try to reduce my paper consumption. Other than, that I love these kits and would certainly recommend!
  • We made Manhattan cocktails of course!
0
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
13 11 202110:25 PM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
High Work but Even Higher Reward! 10/10 recommend.
I hosted this party because my friends and I have always wanted to experience a murder mystery party. And let me tell you this did not disappoint. I ended up hosting the game with all of the characters in play which worked much better than I was expecting. All of the characters had compelling and interesting motivations and things to do. I would definitely recommend this for anyone looking for a higher level of murder mystery party experience. It took a lot more work on the part of the host and guests then any other product I have encountered, but all of that work paid off in making an unforgettable experience.
  • We served food in two courses. I created an extra "role" the chef Helga von Schumann to coordinate the caterers and the food. Our first course was appetizers including mini quiches, teriyaki meatballs, and garnished cheese and crackers. Our next course was dessert where the servers brought out some chocolate cake with whipped cream and berries on the side.
  • We used a navy blue and silver color scheme for the party. Our goal was elegant but not heavy handed. We used blue and silver streamers, table clothes, and balloons (Including a half balloon arch made by one of my guests who knows how to make balloon arches). We accented this with silverware and silver platters for the servers as well as navy blue napkins for the desserts.
3
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
13 11 202111:52 AM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Great fun for adults!
We did Murder in Manhattan as a party for my husband’s 39th birthday over the summer. It was perfect for playing out on our patio, since we were concerned about having people inside due to Covid. There were 9 of us and we had a fantastic time! Our guests really got into character! The party kit was very simple to use, and included character descriptions, prompts, clues and audio clips, Which really gave the party the extra fun touches. We plan on doing more of these mystery parties in the future!
  • Finger foods And appetizers. Crostini, cause skewers, cheese and crackers plates, wine, mini pastries
1
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
11 12 202106:29 AM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
It brought us together as one team with one goal
As part of our year end function we had a surprise murder in manhattan mystery event. The event encouraged all staff members to communicate with each other to try and solve the murder and to get to know each character. It was a great end of the year team building and communication exercise and we look forward to hosting the next one!
  • We had canapes with a cheese and biltong platter for everyone to snack one between scenes
  • We prepacked and prepared props for each person to get into character since it was a surprise event
0
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
30 10 202102:59 PM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Great night had by all, only a few suggestions!
All in all, a great night was had for our Murder in Manhattan party. A lot of guests commented that they had been to other Murder Mystery parties before, but none had been this organized. There is a lot of work to go into planning this one out and you do need to take a few hours to read the story and the character backgrounds of all playing. Some guests will have studied their sheets, but others who want to drink and relax will come to you with questions on their character, so you need to know all backgrounds pretty deeply.

Prep is key! The materials had everything needed, but I did find it a bit difficult to locate specific character sheets, and key story data in the long 170 page PDF. What would be helpful would be to have the pdf titled with sections on the left hand side in your PDF viewer that you can quickly click to when you need to locate something. I also think that a great document to include would be a summarized story for the Party Host on the backgrounds and motive for the killer to easier understand the arching story. I had to flip through the killers character sheets and few other spots within the PDF to actually piece together why the killer killed so that I could make it feasible for the guests at the end of the night. Make sure that everyone is pretty quiet when the lights go out! A few people gasped right away and started screaming and they could not hear the audio file for the murder. Best to play it on a good speaker, not your phone or computer. People immediately wanted to talk and ham up their character reaction during this part. I also found that the dead body clue is a bit redundant so feel free to leave that one out of the scavenger hunt. Guests are searching for things to give them more information, but at this point they have already seen the real dead body during the murder, so a few guests were confused that the dead body clue token did not have more information.

A few things I would do next time is prepare a real locked cellphone with notes in it on the 4 clues, a real file folder with the files inside, and perhaps a plastic play knife with blood on it. Guests REALLY got into this part and while the paper tokens were helpful, it was hard to pretend they were a real item with information on them. You could even go as far as to pre record Jo's camera footage and play it for all the guests! So many ways to be creative with this one, and everyone really enjoyed it.
2
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
08 08 202103:54 PM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Fancy & Fun!
Murder in Manhattan was an absolute blast. Guests loved the opportunity to dress extra fancy and have drinks at their beck & call. Overall the game was easy to conduct and by the end of the night, multiple people were guessed as murderers which was fun!
  • Hired a bartender to make it extra classy! Upscaled “cocktail” attire to ball gowns! Laminated the name tags!
1
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments
22 06 202101:38 PM
  • more than 3 year(s)
  • Game Rating:
Last day of school murder!
I used the party as a last day of school activity for my 7th graders. We were able to complete it in a 90-minute block. The kids had a blast!
  • cupcakes, fruit punch, and individual bags of chips
1
0
Reply
Show more comments (-2) Hide comments

1-15 of 118

Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. ...
  7. 8
What kind of abuse are you reporting?
    Please, wait...